10 Moissanite Problems You Should Know Before Buying

Moissanite has become one of the most talked-about alternatives to diamonds in the jewelry world. With its incredible sparkle, affordability, and durability, many people are choosing moissanite engagement rings, necklaces, and iced-out jewelry instead of traditional diamonds. However, like every gemstone, moissanite is not without its drawbacks. Before making your purchase, it’s important to understand the potential issues so you can make an informed decision.

If you’re shopping for moissanite jewelry, you can explore stunning collections at GetIcedOut.co, where you’ll find high-quality iced-out pieces designed to fit every style.

Below, we’ll explore 10 common moissanite problems you should be aware of before buying, along with tips to avoid them.

1. Moissanite Can Look Too Sparkly (Disco Ball Effect)

One of the most noticeable differences between moissanite and diamond is the sparkle. Moissanite has a higher refractive index (2.65–2.69) compared to diamonds (2.42), which means it reflects more light. This gives moissanite an intense rainbow-like sparkle, often described as a “disco ball effect.”

While some people love this colorful fire, others feel it looks artificial or too flashy. Under direct sunlight or bright LED lights, moissanite can sometimes appear overly dazzling, which may not appeal to someone who wants a diamond-like look.

Solution: If you prefer a subtler sparkle, opt for larger moissanite stones in antique cuts like cushion or emerald cut, as they produce less rainbow dispersion.

2. Color Tints in Larger Stones

Although high-quality moissanite is marketed as “colorless,” larger stones (over 2 carats) may sometimes reveal faint yellow, gray, or green undertones in certain lighting conditions. These tints are more noticeable in comparison to a flawless diamond.

Solution: Always choose DEF color grade moissanite if you want a clear, diamond-like appearance. Reputable jewelers, such as GetIcedOut.co, offer premium moissanite with minimal color variance.

3. Not a Diamond Substitute for Everyone

Moissanite is often marketed as a diamond alternative, but some buyers feel disappointed when they realize it doesn’t look exactly the same. While it has brilliance and durability, its optical properties are unique, and trained eyes (or jewelers) can distinguish it from a diamond.

Solution: If you want moissanite, embrace it as its own beautiful gemstone rather than expecting it to mimic diamonds perfectly.

4. Price Confusion in the Market

Moissanite is much more affordable than diamonds, but some jewelers price it inconsistently. A 1-carat moissanite ring may range from $200 to $800 depending on quality and seller reputation. Some unethical sellers may overprice moissanite, trying to market it closer to diamond pricing.

Solution: Always compare prices from trusted jewelry stores. Online platforms like GetIcedOut.co offer transparent pricing for their iced-out moissanite jewelry.

5. Durability Concerns with Daily Wear

Moissanite is second only to diamonds on the Mohs hardness scale (9.25 vs. 10). However, this does not make it completely indestructible. It is highly scratch-resistant but not scratch-proof. Daily wear, especially on rings, can sometimes cause minor surface abrasions over years of use.

Solution: Regularly clean your moissanite jewelry with mild soap and warm water, and store it separately to avoid scratches from other gems.

6. Ethical Marketing Issues

Moissanite is a lab-created gemstone, which makes it eco-friendly and conflict-free. However, some sellers mislead buyers by labeling it as a “synthetic diamond” or “diamond alternative” without clarifying the differences. This can cause confusion and unmet expectations for customers.

Solution: Buy from jewelers who provide full disclosure about their gemstones, such as GetIcedOut.co, which highlights moissanite as a unique luxury choice.

7. Possible Cloudiness Over Time

While high-quality moissanite doesn’t fade, cheap or poorly cut stones may appear cloudy after years of wear due to dirt buildup, oils, or low craftsmanship. This isn’t an inherent flaw of moissanite but rather an issue with low-grade stones.

Solution: Invest in premium quality moissanite and clean it regularly. Professional cleaning can restore its brilliance easily.

8. Difficult Resale Value

Unlike diamonds, moissanite doesn’t hold its value well in the resale market. Since it is lab-created and widely available, pawnshops and resale markets offer much less for moissanite compared to what you originally paid.

Solution: Buy moissanite for its beauty and affordability, not as a long-term investment.

9. Limited Availability of Natural Moissanite

Natural moissanite is extremely rare, found only in small quantities in meteorites and limited mining areas. Almost all moissanite in jewelry is lab-grown. While this makes it sustainable, some buyers who prefer natural gems may find this disappointing.

Solution: Understand that lab-created moissanite is the standard and actually a benefit for affordability and eco-friendliness.

10. Confusion with Diamond Simulants

Moissanite is often confused with cubic zirconia (CZ) or other diamond simulants. Many inexperienced buyers assume moissanite is the same as CZ, which is much cheaper and less durable. This misconception can sometimes make it harder to explain its value to others.

Solution: Educate yourself and others. Moissanite is far superior to cubic zirconia, with higher durability, brilliance, and longevity.

Conclusion

Moissanite is a stunning gemstone that provides incredible sparkle, durability, and affordability. However, understanding its drawbacks is essential to ensure you know exactly what you’re buying. From excessive sparkle to resale value challenges, being aware of these issues will help you decide if moissanite is the right choice for you.

If you’re ready to explore moissanite jewelry that blends luxury with affordability, check out GetIcedOut.co for a premium collection of iced-out chains, rings, and accessories.